07 January 2024

Adams - rooster or hen wings?

Catskill legend Ed van Put's favorite fly to fish is the Adams.

Recently someone said that Ed insists that a correctly tied Adams uses round tipped rooster hackle point wings or it is an incorrectly tied Adams. Ed grows his own grizzly as pretty much round tipped rooster have been bred out these days of genetic hackle.

As historically this is correct, I wanted to see how different a hackle tip of a rooster and a hen turns out side-by-side. Which one do you prefer?


Left rooster cape, right hen cape (from the Darbees, bought somewhere in the early 90s)
























Rooster hackle tips




Hen hackle tips




























Work in progress





























Rooster wing Adams



























Hen wing Adams






















































Adams flies tied by their originator, Leonard Halladay of Mayfield, Michigan. Note the spent-wing tying style




























































No comments: